“I work for Erskine Design in Nottingham. Which is nice. You've got choices, you can visit my homepage, take a look at the available downloads or view the blog archives. Please contact me whenever you like. Also, why not subscribe to the RSS feed.”
So I’m sitting in the kitchen watching TV and doing some work. On the TV is a documentary that follows the same rules as about one fifth of all documentaries on at this time of day… is A better than B? Is C a rip-off when compared to D - exploding the myths about ‘E’ - You’ll get fat as f**k if you eat ‘F’… you get the picture.
This particular show features a science person (or is that a person of science?) who is filling up her shopping basket with food stuffs only if advertising claims, or claims about their greatness can be scientifically quantified/proven. As you would expect most food products come back from the test with a ‘we don’t really know’ result. Which is fair enough, but what I have a problem with is the investigation into organic foods. It seems to have raised the same bullshit discussion that usually pisses me off.
Question: Is organic food any good?
Reasoning: can it be proven that organic food is better for you, more nutritious or tastier than non-organic foods?
I couldn’t care less. Organic food is no worse for you, it probably won’t taste significantly worse than non-organic food, I don’t buy organic food because I believe it will make me a super-human, I buy organic food (but not exclusively) because I think that intensive farming practice needs reigning in. Massive mistakes have been made in the past when the effects of pesticides have been misjudged not just on humans but on other animals and plants. I like the idea that people can move away from the idea that if something produces bigger, fatter juicier food - do it. Like grinding up sheep bits to feed cattle - BSE anyone? Organic production methods would not have allowed this - cows eat plants, not sheep (ha ha, imagine that though, a couple of cows standing casually at the edge of a sheep field - perhaps whistling and trying to blend in - before pouncing - udders swinging as chunks of fleece fly out of the chaos). Simple.
Organic produce is not solely concerned with taste and nutrition, it is concerned with better food production practices. It is not about engineering food to taste better and it is not just about your enjoyment of food.
It is probably also worth mentioning that I have just eaten a whole bar of Green & Blacks cherry chocolate (yum yum yum), and I am beginning to shake a bit.
Ross ~ Wednesday, Feb 27th 2008 @ 21:13:34
I totally agree. I do not buy organic food for it’s taste, social reasons etc just for ethical reasons!
Organic Food Information ~ Thursday, Feb 28th 2008 @ 13:00:51
It’s true, people should be more careful with pesticides. It took a long time for people to realise how dangerous DDT was…
Organic whole foods ~ Saturday, Mar 1st 2008 @ 20:39:06
I agree with you except I was interested by this statement: “it probably won’t taste significantly worse than non-organic food”
I think most people know how much better organic food tastes! It is significantly better in most cases! So much so that you can often tell that you are eating organic just by the taste!
Glen ~ Saturday, Mar 1st 2008 @ 20:47:59
I agree, personally I think in many cases organic food does taste better, the point I was trying to make though is that if taste and health benefits are removed from the equation it still makes sense.
It is unlikely that an organic version of a food type will taste “bad” - if it tastes better that’s a bonus - not the sole reason for buying it.
What I don’t like is when people say “ I bought organic xxxx last week, it didn’t taste much different to the stuff I usually buy, I won’t bother next time.”
Graham ~ Friday, Mar 14th 2008 @ 14:23:48
That’s just missing the point entirely, if you buy irganically there’s reasons behind it and not because it’s a different type of product on the shelfs to buy. I would say those people are mis-informed. I eat organically for teh environmental reasons and if tastes the same or better then I’ll be buying that product again!
Diabetes Recipe ~ Friday, Apr 18th 2008 @ 09:05:49
i don’t knw whether organic food has more nutrition or not, but for sure it tastes lot better than the chemical crap we buy from supermarket.
Corporate Hampers ~ Tuesday, Jun 3rd 2008 @ 02:23:44
To me, organic products are all about taste. Genetic engineered foods also have good nutritution and sometimes more than organic foods, but taste is not the same. However, in this recent crisis of world food shortage and the way food price is going high, there is no substitute to genericly engineered food which produces more
Organic Hampers ~ Monday, Jun 16th 2008 @ 20:05:53
The production of our food is so important and you are right to seperate and highlight this. As the recent documentaries on chicken farming et al have shown, the public will not put up with it - but quite often they don’t know about it.
Fortunately the price gap is decreasing which again will encourage more organic food production and less of the bad mass farming practices.
hinduja ~ Sunday, Jul 13th 2008 @ 16:39:07
I just don’t know whether organic foods are good or bad in healthy. But as far i know organic foods are good in taste so i prefer it more than any other foods that are available in super market.Yes, i have also hears about DDT’s.
JWP ~ Tuesday, Jul 29th 2008 @ 05:34:27
It’s more healthy too
nutrition advice ~ Thursday, Jul 31st 2008 @ 11:14:15
Great article. I’m definitely going to share it with a few people
ram ~ Friday, Aug 1st 2008 @ 19:10:12
However, in this recent crisis of world food shortage and the way food price is going high, there is no substitute to genericly engineered food which produces more. I just don’t know whether organic foods are good or bad in healthy.
Lose Fat Naturally ~ Tuesday, Aug 5th 2008 @ 02:39:20
I agree with this statement who knows what the long term effects of putting all these chemicals into our body, “ I buy organic food because I think that intensive farming practice needs reigning in. Massive mistakes have been made in the past when the effects of pesticides have been misjudged not just on humans but on other animals and plants”.
Glyconutrient ~ Saturday, Aug 9th 2008 @ 23:50:26
Great stuff.. it goes without saying that organic food is the way ahead.!
EQ2 Platinum ~ Friday, Aug 29th 2008 @ 12:38:14
It’s really important to understand the usefulness og organic food for every living being. Also it’s important for farmers to know use of limited pesticide. So people should have more organic food for better health.
sdfsdf34r ~ Thursday, Oct 30th 2008 @ 12:29:20
See this many wev bages it is best health site!!!,
acai berry ~ Tuesday, Nov 11th 2008 @ 17:12:44
hey. I must mention here that i echo the exact same sentiments.
it’s not just about making the taste of food better by modifying or hybridising it with something or the other...its about supporting agricultural practices as well.
Hydroponics Store Downtown Toronto Canada ~ Tuesday, Dec 2nd 2008 @ 16:25:57
This is really true, I mean, it fresh so it healthy and good for us, we should be buying organic foods not just for our good but also for ethical reasons.
Efdpcfbg ~ Saturday, Dec 13th 2008 @ 17:23:13
Thanks!,